Monday, June 13th, 2011




Drop Dead Diva

Outstanding Comedy Series

Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series
Brooke Elliott

… and all other categories


  Cynopsis Media presents 

Before the Ballots: Comedy

2011 Primetime Emmy® Award Pre-Nomination Special Report
by Daisy Whitney

Good morning. It’s Monday, June 13, 2011, and this is the 4th of a five-part series predicting the nominees for this year’s primetime Emmy® Awards.  Today’s installment looking at the potential nominees for Outstanding Comedy Series.

BEFORE THE BALLOTS: Outstanding Comedy Series
By Daisy Whitney

Win an Emmy one year and then bam! – you’re the front runner the next one. Funny how that works, but that’s why Modern Family seems the show to beat in the best comedy series category. Leading TV critics, Emmy® handicappers and TV executives alike agree that the second-year ratings juggernaut and critics darling will not only land a nod, but will also have the big bullseye on its back as the comedy to beat all summer long.

“Modern Family is scary good for only its second season. It has the best shot of any network show,” said Frank Nicotero, Comedian and Host of Yahoo TV’s Primetime in No Time.

The Academy of Television Arts and Sciences will officially reveal nominees the morning of July 14. According to Emmy® watchers, at least three shows are virtual locks for best comedy series nods – Modern Family, 30 Rock and The Office. All have won at least once, with 30 Rock having earned the trophy three times. That makes them the usual suspects this go-round, but critics say there’s good reason for near shoe-in status: they all boast strong writing and strong casts and they aren’t afraid to take risks.

But the field is wide, and experts expect to see some fresh faces in the lineup too, such as Parks and Recreation, Community and perhaps even Hot in Cleveland, driven by the career renaissance of the show’s fan favorite Betty White. Musical hit Glee will likely draw serious votes, along with dramedy Nurse Jackie, and never-been-nominated The Big Bang Theory.

The Usual Suspects

Veteran winner 30 Rock collected the gold in its first three seasons, but lost to newcomer Modern Family last year. Variety said the workplace comedy “bounced back” this year with a “killer” fifth season. Other critics too are listing 30 Rock as the show with the strongest chance to beat Modern Family. Then there’s The Office, which won gold in 2006. This year it’s betting on a strong sentimental tide, given that Steve Carrell’s final season just ended, said Maureen Ryan, Television Critic for AOL TV. That sentimentality, though, may translate into more votes for Carell in the acting category rather than the show. Ryan, like others, said Modern Family’s sophomore run will lure lots of votes. “The show’s still a big hit and brings the funny often enough,” she said.

Plus, the writing on Modern Family is “exceptional” and the cast is “strong,” said Jennifer Caserta, Executive VP and General Manager for IFC. Her network is pitching hard for buzzy variety show Portlandia to captivate voters. IFC hosted an Emmy screening in Los Angeles in April with the cast and hopes the hipster chatter surrounding the Fred Armisen-led variety show will win it a nod. 

A Wider Net

After Jim Parsons’ acting win last year in the comedy field, a number of TV experts believe that network TV ratings powerhouse Big Bang Theory will earn attention in the comedy series category. “It’s about time this show and its entire ensemble, not just the very talented Jim Parsons, was recognized,” Ryan said. Glee, which garnered a freshman year nod, is likely to gain a nomination this year too, even though most critics don’t expect the musical to win. Dramedy Nurse Jackie nabbed a slot on the ballot last year and will likely this year too in large part because the Academy loves Edie Falco, but critics have cited storyline problems with the program this year. Still, both of those shows  Nurse Jackie and Glee  demonstrate just how genre-bending the TV fare of today has become, Caserta said. “It’s not as cut and dried as it used to be, which makes TV very refreshing. And it’s good for TV and just good for viewers who are exposed to new and different things and to entertainment that bends their mind a bit.”

Parks and Recreation also has a strong shot at a nod, especially following the romance-fueled third season and the addition of Rob Lowe to the cast. With strong characterizations and deadpan humor, the show is a strong contender, experts say.

Dark Horses

NBC may also find nomination happiness with Community, which experts have lauded especially for its writing. Fox’s Raising Hope has been the rare freshman breakout comedy, as has TVland’s Hot in Cleveland, a show that’s been cited as a contender in Variety and award prediction site . Hot in Cleveland’s buzz is more focused on Betty White and her longevity though, rather than the show as a whole. But that may be enough, especially since the show received a SAG nomination for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series.

This 5-part series of 2011 Primetime Emmy® Award Pre-Nomination Special Reports are available on the Cynopsis website in our special Primetime Emmy®2011 section.

Later —
Daisy Whitney for Cynopsis

Cynopsis Ad Sales:
Mike Farina – VP/Business Development & Sales – 203-218-6480 / [email protected]
Classifieds – Trish Pihonak- 203-381-9096 / [email protected]

To subscribe to any Cynopsis edition(s) click here .
To unsubscribe from Cynopsis, click here

Cynopsis Media LLC
65 Lantern Road
Stratford, CT 06614
Ph: 203.381.9096
Fx: 203.386.8855

All outgoing e-mails are scanned and sent out virus free. Copyright Cynopsis 2011

Related Stories

06/06/23: Apple unveils Vision Pro

Apple unveils Vision Pro

Tuesday June 6, 2023 Today’s Premieres A&E: Customer Wars at 9p; Storage Wars at 10p ESPN: 30 for 30: The Luckiest Guy in the World at 8p HBO: Burden of Proof at 9p History: Beyond Skinwalker Ranch at 11p ID: Late Night Lockup at 10p Paramount+: Destination: European Nights IN THE NEWS “To those whose […]

06/05/23: Cynopsis Media Tech Update

Big reveal for "Top Chef" host Padma Lakshmi

Monday June 5, 2023 Amazon has agreed to payments to settle two federal lawsuits alleging that the tech giant violated users’ privacy through its Alexa voice assistant and its Ring doorbell cameras. The FTC found that Amazon violated children’s privacy law COPPA by keeping voice recordings of children, in some cases failing to honor deletion […]

06/05/23: Big reveal for “Top Chef” host Padma Lakshmi

Big reveal for "Top Chef" host Padma Lakshmi

Monday June 5, 2023 Today’s Premieres Fox: Stars on Mars at 8p; Crime Scene Kitchen at 9p Freeform: Cruel Summer at 9p Hulu: Age of Influence Nat Geo: America’s National Parks at 9p NBC: American Ninja Warrior at 8p Netflix: Barracuda Queens IN THE NEWS YouTube will no longer remove content that advances false claims […]

06/04/23: Cynopsis Jobs


SR. DIRECTOR, PRODUCT MANAGEMENT SHOUT! FACTORY LOS ANGELES P&L responsibility, ownership over all aspects of a project, standalone releases or a licensed library of titles. Works w/production, publicity, creative services, distribution/sales, digital, finance, legal, acquisitions & licensors to best position the project for success. 7+ yrs of exp. in marketing, business development, or product management. […]

06/02/23: “The Drew Barrymore Show” is the fastest-growing talker on TV

Friday June 2, 2023 Today’s Premieres Amazon: Deadloch; Shiny Happy People: Duggar Family Secrets; With Love Food: Guy’s All-American Road Trip at 9p HBO: Painting with John at 11p Hulu: Searching for Soul Food Netflix: Scoop; Valeria; Vortex Paramount+: Love Allways; Queen of the Universe Saturday’s Premieres HGTV: Vacation House Rules at 9p Weather Channel: […]