The Curious Case of a Hit True Crime Series

ID’s hit docuseries “The  Curious Case of Natalia Grace” follows the story of a couple whose adoption goes awry when they come to believe their little girl is actually a sociopathic woman with a hormonal disorder. Shannon Evangelista, Executive Producer and co-founder of Hot Snakes Media and the creator of the true crime tale, tells how the series came to be.

What drew you to this story?

The amount of twists and turns allowed for complex loud storytelling to be delivered which is really on brand for Hot Snakes Media as a company. It’s a complex story that requires us as producers to get fully embedded in the subject matter and given our combined experience as prosecutors and in network news that’s a situation we thrive in.

How were you able to gain such incredible access to the players?

Gaining this level of access took a lot of persistence, patience, and perseverance – we never let up. 

We set up roots in Indiana and became part of the landscape, which fostered trust and strong relationships with those who were involved in the story. Gaining access to stories and people isn’t automatic; it takes a lot of real work and years of experience.

Were you surprised by the series’ success?

We are very grateful for the show’s success, and we cannot wait to share more of what we can do with the upcoming “NataliaSpeaks” documentary and many more beyond that. We are most excited about pitching our upcoming slate of true crime development which includes series on the FBI’s decades long secret investigation into the America’s Queen of Soul, Aretha Franklin. We are also developing a series about the controversial guardian of Bam Magera, Lima Jevremovic and the #freebam movement, where we will provide exclusive interviews from Bam’s family, Lima herself and Jackass co-stars such as Steve-O.

Related Stories

Cynopsis 01/08/26: Yahoo Integrates Agentic AI

Thursday January 8, 2026    IN THE NEWS As expected, the board of Warner Bros. Discovery advised shareholders to reject the latest amended takeover offer from Paramount. “Your Board negotiated a merger with Netflix that maximizes value while mitigating downside risks, and we unanimously believe the Netflix merger is in your best interest,” […]

01/07/26: Cynopsis Jobs

jobs8

Wednesday January 7, 2026 CONVERGENT TV WORLD 2026 The Voices Guiding the Next Era of Convergent TV As the industry hits a turning point, Convergent TV World delivers the clarity leaders need. Laura Martin of Needham & Company opens the event with a keynote on AI acceleration, investment shifts, and the rebuild of measurement—followed by […]

Cynopsis 01/07/26: NBCU Looks to a Legendary February

Wednesday January 7, 2026    IN THE NEWS NBC reports it has sold all of its ad inventory for the upcoming Winter Olympic Games – and the sellout was the earliest the company has ever recorded. The Games, from Milan Cortina, Italy, will be part of what NBC dubs a “Legendary February” […]

TV Ad Measurement Is Broken. Tatari Wants to Fix It

On this episode of Inside the Stack, Cynopsis’ Lynn Leahey sits down with Benjamin Heaton, Senior Director of Product Management at Tatari, to talk about why TV ad measurement is breaking down, and what it will take to fix it. They dig into signal loss, why traditional identifiers no longer work, and why most clean […]

CynCity

Cynsiders

Instagram